Elder Abuse
Verdict: $238,341
Elderly care home resident
claimed negligence after developing stage IV bedsore (Deckard v. Araville
Residential Care Home, San Mateo County Superior Court, Plaintiff attorney: Kathryn
A. Stebner).
Alleged Contraindication
Verdict: Defense
ALS patient's family
alleged that an anti-anxiety medication was contraindictated, but failed to
prove doctor's negligence caused the patient's death (Woerner v. Hay, Los
Angeles County Superior Court, Defense attorney: Yuk K. Law).
Pregnancy Discrimination
Verdict: $150,000
Private golf club allegedly
fired restaurant server to avoid accommodating her need for pregnancy leave –
jury awarded $0 in special/general damages, but $150,000 in punitive damages (Moore
v. JMK Golf LLC, San Benito County Superior Court, Plaintiff attorney: William
L. Marder).
Eggshell Plaintiff
Settlement: $400,000
Purported eggshell
plaintiff allegedly suffered back injuries in sideswipe collision (Drennan v.
Confidential, Santa Barbara County Superior Court, Plaintiff attorney: Otto L.
Haselhoff).
Jaw Osteonecrosis
Verdict: $2,162,000
Cancer patient claimed
products liability after allegedly developing osteonecrosis of the jaw from
cancer medication (Georges v. Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corp., Central District
Federal Court, Plaintiff attorney: John A. Girardi).
Artwork Accident
Settlement: $2,050,000
Artwork fell onto a fast
food customer allegedly causing lumbar disk protrusions and denervation (Rubalcaba
De Reynoso v. Confidential, Los Angeles County Superior Court, Plaintiff
attorney: Wayne McClean).
Starbucks Fall
Verdict: $500,000
Plaintiff allegedly slipped
and fell on mopped floor at Starbucks causing a bimalleolar ankle fracture (Lyles
v. Starbucks Corporation, San Diego County Superior Court, Plaintiff attorney: John
H. Gomez).
Insurance Bad Faith
Verdict: $2,730,010
Insurer attempted to
rescind policy following a house fire and allegedly falsely claimed plaintiffs
did not live in the home but used it as a halfway house for persons released
from prison and/or in a substance abuse rehabilitation program (Douglas v.
Fidelity National Insurance Company, Alameda County Superior Court, Plaintiff attorney:
J. Edward Kerley).
Birth Injury
Settlement: $9,975,000
Family alleged that an
obstetrician, perinatologist and hospital staff negligently delayed the
delivery of a newborn in distress causing hypoxic ischemic brain injury,
cerebral palsy and numerous other severe injuries, (Confidential v.
Confidential, Confidential Venue, Plaintiff attorney: Kenneth M. Sigelman).
Disability Discrimination
Settlement: $100,500
Demoted McDonald's manager
claimed disability discrimination due to his mental impairments (U.S. Equal
Employment Opportunity Commission v. Alia Corporation, Eastern District Federal
Court, Plaintiff attorney: Anna Y. Park).
Editor’s Note: California Bar Journal publishes this abbreviated summary of important trials in California provided by Trials Digest. To report your case results, go to west.thomson.com/trialsdigest/form.aspx or call 415-344-3952.